"No defeat is made up entirely of defeat-- since//the world it opens is always a place// formerly// unsuspected." (ln 14-17). It takes a strong will to see the positive in defeat and while these lines give the appearance of hope the last lines of the poem counteract it: "what we have lost in the anticipation--// a decent follows,// endless and indestructible ." (ln 41-43). The disjointed lines which seem to wander away, fragmented and seemingly concentric develop the feeling of an emotional descent. But given Williams' recent paralysis and inability to function physically as well as he used to I believe this descent is more physical. This is further reinforced by the way the lines are laid out on the page. The body of both the writer and the poem are broken, fragmented, and dissimilar to their earlier counterparts. The Williams before this poem was one who could read and write and practice medicine with ease, the poems before "The Descent" appeared normally on the page; aligning with the left margin and flowing forward. None of Williams' earlier poems given in this anthology have lines that start in the middle of the page or long spaces between a word and it's period. The rambling feel of the words within the poem along with the retreat into memory and thought display the lost and searching feelings displayed in the poem. It is almost like a stream of consciousness journey as a man tries to rationalize what his purpose in life will be after an important moment in his life. There is no going back but there is no clear way to move forwards.
(Title from this song.)
Hey, Emily. I enjoyed reading your post on Williams' "The Descent." I like how you included background on Williams' life and utilized that background in your reading. What a beautiful, honest poem! I really enjoy how Williams’ way of looking at defeat and loss enables him to see those adverse experiences/realities in his life with some measure of positivity and with implications that may not yet be "realized" within his mind, as it is his mind on display wrestling with his memory. Nice post. :)
ReplyDeleteWOW! Thank you for providing such great detail on Williams the poet. I researched too much specifically about the poems and not about the man himself! This post really brings to light many motives for his poems that take place after all of those events. Nicely done!
ReplyDeleteEmily, thanks for your post. Your observations about this poem and insight behind Williams as a poet! Also, after reading so many poets I didn't take the time to compare several poems of one poet as you did. I think the difference in structure from this poem to the rest of his work presented in the Anthology is noteworthy! Good job, friend.
ReplyDeleteHey Emily, I really enjoyed reading your thoughts about Williams. Even though we are past this section in our reading I wanted to go back and look through ones I had missed. I especially like how you connected "the word became flesh" with the idea of understanding the the source of the word. Thanks for posting!
ReplyDeleteTanya Neuman